The World Health Organization has declared hepatitis C as a global health problem, with approximately 3% of the world's population infected with HCV.1 Egypt has the highest prevalence of HCV in the world at 12 to 13%.2 Approximately 20% of blood donors are HCV Ab positive.3 Iron overload in the liver induces oxidative stress, which was a factor of cell membrane damage, DNA instability, and mutagenesis. Due to these effects, iron can be considered a proinflammatory, profibrogenic factor, and a potential carcinogen. Since the implementation of serological diagnostic tests for HCV identification, elevated serum iron overload indices or appearance of iron deposits in liver cells have been observed in 10 to 40% of patients with CHC and 50% of patients suffering both from CHC and hepatocellular carcinoma.4 Some investigations have shown an association between elevated serum iron indices or high hepatic iron concentration (HIC) and the lack of SVR in CHC patients,5 whereas others have shown that there is no positive correlation between HIC and decreased frequency of SVR.6 In 2006, Bonkovsky et al7 found the presence of iron in endothelial cells with triad iron score (not global iron score) as a predictor of decreased SVR. These contradictory results from different parts of the world may possibly have their source in ethnic differences and the variable polymorphisms of iron metabolism-related genes found in different populations. The aim of this work is to assess the value of HFE C282Y gene mutations as a predictor of SVR to antiviral treatment in Egyptian patients with CHC virus infection.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The study was conducted on 140 CHC patients (based on the presence of persistently elevated liver enzymes for at least 6 months and detection of HCV ribonucleic acid by PCR technique) who took antiviral treatment. The patients were divided into two groups: Group I consisted of 70 patients who achieved SVR after antiviral treatment, and group II consisted of 70 patients who did not respond to antiviral treatment (NR). Patients with malignancy, decompensated cirrhosis, hepatitis B virus coinfection, or other causes of liver disease were excluded. All patients were subjected to full history taking, clinical examination, laboratory investigations including liver and kidney biochemical profile, alfa fetoprotein (AFP), viral load, and specific tests of our study: Complete iron profile, molecular study for HFE (C282Y).
The data about patient profiles are shown in Table 1. As regards age and sex, there was no statistically significant difference between SVR and NR groups (with p-value 0.140 and 0.091 respectively). Also, the whole liver profile did not show any statistically significant difference. A high statistically significant difference was observed between NR and SVR regarding GG, GA, and AA genotype, which was absent in SVR group (Table 2). Sustained virological response was associated with allele A and NR was associated with allele G (Table 2). Concerning iron status, there was statistically significant difference between SVR and NR groups regarding different parameters of iron levels [S iron, TIBC, transferrin, TS % and sTfR)]. However, no statistical significance was documented for S ferritin between the two groups (Table 3).
|Nonresponders||Responders||p-value||OR (95% CI)|
|OR: Odds ratio|
Chronic hepatitis C patients have frequently elevated serum iron stores and elevated HIC, which has been associated with a poor response to interferon-alfa.8 The mechanism by which iron accumulates in liver infected with chronic HCV has not yet been established. Serum iron and ferritin levels were increased in patients with CHC because of their release from hepatocellular stores in association with cell necrosis.9 Individuals with serum iron levels in the upper range of normal as a result of genetic polymorphisms or a high iron diet may be predisposed to develop more severe chronic HCV infections.9 Several studies10 have found that heterozygous C282Y mutations are associated with hepatic iron loading in CHC patients. Iron overload seems to impair antigen-specific immune responses by decreasing the generation of T cells and by impairment of natural killer and T helper cell function. Piperno et al11 suggested that iron overload in patients with hemochromatosis may contribute to the persistence of HCV infection, and iron overload may in theory promote viral replication. The amount of hepatic iron has been identified as one of these factors that adversely affect the likelihood of response to interferon-alfa; those patients with higher hepatic iron content are less likely to respond to interferon therapy.12 In our study, there was a correlation between HFE gene mutation and iron overload. We considered transferrin saturation index (TSI) as the most specific and sensitive parameter in identifying iron overload as it showed a significant statistical difference between responder group (27.5%) and NR (34.5%) group with p-value <0.001. But there was no significant difference for serum ferritin, S iron (p = 0.02), TIBC (p > 0.001) transferrin (p = 0.016), sTfR (p > 0.001), but our study provides evidence supporting that the HFE gene mutations are associated with significant abnormalities of iron metabolism and suggests that patients with CHC accumulate iron as a result of interplay between genetic and acquired factors. We noticed that A allele is associated with higher iron parameters and lower TIBC and the homozygous mutation (AA) is associated with higher iron indices. The wildtype (GG) is lower than the heterozygous mutation (GA) genotype. There is a statistically significant difference between gene polymorphism (AA, GA, GG) and iron parameters with p-value <0.001 for each of S. iron, TIBC, TS%, and S. ferritin, with p-value 0.033 as regarding transferrin and by 0.026 as regarding sTfR. Sustained virological response rates were lower among patients with HFE gene mutations compared with those with HFE gene wildtype. In our study, 54 of 140 (38.5%) patients have mutation [50 heterozygous (GA) and 4 homozygous (AA)] and 86 have no mutation (wild-type GG). All homo and 45 from heterozygous mutation did not respond to treatment; 92% (92.9%) of the SVR group have no (GG) mutation and 7% carry C282Y mutation (GA), while 64.3% of NR group carry heterozygous C282Y mutation (GA), 5.7% carry homozygous mutation (AA), and 30% are without mutation (GG). Therefore, HFE gene mutations may act synergically with CHC in the development of liver damage, predicting a higher rate of nonresponse to therapy. Our results correlate with those of Sini et al,13 who stated that 69 CHC patients with end-of-treatment response were lower among patients with HFE gene mutations compared with those with HFE gene wildtype (p = 0.005) and TSI showed a significant statistical difference between HFE mutant patients (50%) and wild-type homozygotes (43.4%) (p < 0.01). Coelho-Borges et al14 had similar results in 2002 when they studied 44 Brazilian patients. They showed that SVR was achieved in 0 of 16 patients with HFE gene mutations and 11 (41%) of 27 patients without HFE gene mutations (p = 0.002). They concluded that heterozygosity for H63D and/or C282Y HFE gene mutation predicted absence of SVR to combination treatment with interferon and ribavirin in patients with CHC, non-1 genotype and serum ferritin levels above 500 ng/mL. Our results did not correlate with those of Li et al,15 who showed that H63D mutation was associated with a significantly higher SVR rate [odds ratio (OR) = 1.60, 95% confidence interval (CI): 1.09—2.34, p = 0.020], while the C282Y mutation was not (OR = 1.19, 95% CI: 0.71—1.98, p = 0.510). We do not agree with Lebray et al16 who based on a large cohort of HCV-infected patients found an opposite effect of iron blood parameters and the H63D mutation on the antiviral efficacy of interferon-alfa used alone or in combination therapy with exception of six C282Y heterozygote patients that displayed no sustained response; but this group was too small to allow the detection of a significant difference with any other group. Increased iron stores may affect the course of viral infection in various ways: First, increased HIC may facilitate viral replication and in vitro data suggest that iron facilitates HCV replication in cultured hepatocytes.17 Second, iron loading was demonstrated to enhance HCV pathogenicity.18